The Melody of Love

J. Warren Kerrigan

Jack O'Brien

Norbert A. Myles

'Diamond' Dave

Ethel Phillips

Mary, the nameless

Buck Connors

'Hardpin' Henry

Nell Shipman

Vera Lou

Mae Talbot

Biddy Malone

W.H. Mullen

'Rattlesnake' Pete

T.D. Crittenden

Sheriff

Barry Shipman

Jack O'Brien as a Child (uncredited) (unconfirmed)